Skip to content
Search

Men's Flat Caps: How to Choose Tweed, Wax or Waterproof

  • Christmas Gifts
Flat cap worn with Jack Pyke autumn and winter country clothing

The best men's flat cap for most people is a lined wool tweed cap that fits snugly around the widest part of your head. Choose Harris Tweed if you want the classic look and natural warmth, a waterproof tweed if you spend long, wet days outside, and waxed cotton if you want something tough that shrugs off drizzle and is easy to keep going for years.

This guide is for anyone choosing a flat cap for the shoot, the dog walk, the farm or as a Christmas present, and it covers fabrics, fit, sizing and care, with the caps we would pick from our own range.

Quick picks: men's flat caps compared

Cap Outer Weather protection Best for
Failsworth Stornoway Harris Tweed Harris Tweed, pure virgin wool Natural wool warmth, quilted lining Everyday country wear and gifting
Failsworth Waterproof Country Tweed Lovat Scottish tweed Waterproof, windproof and breathable Wet walks and race days
Harkila Badanloch 100% British wool tweed Water-repellent and wind-resistant Driven and walked-up shooting
Deerhunter Pro Gamekeeper Technical fabric Waterproof, windproof, thornproof Keepers, beaters and rough ground
Jack Pyke Ashcombe Nyco with TPU membrane 5,000mm waterproof rating Hard-wearing cap under £15
Jack Pyke Wax Flat Cap British Millerain waxed cotton Waterproof wax finish Farm work and all-weather wear


Which fabric is best for a flat cap?

Wool tweed is the best all-round fabric for a flat cap because it is warm, breathes well and keeps its shape. The real choice is how much weather protection you need on top of that.

Flat cap worn outdoors with Jack Pyke country clothing

Traditional tweed handles cold, dry days and light showers well. A quilted or satin lining adds warmth and comfort against the forehead.

Waterproof tweed looks the same from the outside but has a treatment or membrane that stops prolonged rain soaking through. If you are out for hours in a wet Cumbrian winter, this is the version we would steer you towards.

Waxed cotton is the most weatherproof of the traditional options and is very hard-wearing. The trade-off is that it is cooler than tweed in a cold wind, a little stiffer, and it needs re-waxing now and again.

Technical fabrics, such as membrane-backed shooting caps, give the most protection and are often thornproof, but they look slightly less classic than pure wool.

What makes Harris Tweed different?

Harris Tweed is protected by its own Act of Parliament. Under the Harris Tweed Act 1993, it must be handwoven by islanders at their homes in the Outer Hebrides from pure virgin wool dyed and spun there, and the Harris Tweed Authority inspects the cloth before it can carry the Orb Mark.

Failsworth Stornoway Harris Tweed flat cap in pattern 2022

In practice that means a dense, characterful cloth that wears in rather than wears out. Over the last three months, Failsworth's Stornoway Harris Tweed caps have been our best-selling tweed flat caps across several patterns. The Stornoway in pattern 2022 has a sewn-down brim, a side pin, a quilted lining and a grosgrain sweatband, which is what makes it comfortable for a full day rather than just a trip to the pub.

Harris Tweed is not fully waterproof. If most of your wear is in heavy rain, look at a waterproof tweed instead.


Which flat cap is best for wet weather?

For a traditional look in proper rain, choose a waterproof tweed. For hard work and rough ground, a technical or waxed cap is the more practical choice.

The Failsworth Waterproof Country Tweed cap uses a Lovat Scottish tweed with a windowpane check, treated with Porelle to make it waterproof, windproof and breathable. It is fully lined with a sweatband, so it reads as a smart tweed cap but copes with a wet Pennine walk.

If you are beating, keepering or walking through gorse and brambles, the Deerhunter Pro Gamekeeper flat cap is waterproof, windproof, thornproof and breathable, and is designed to match the Pro Gamekeeper clothing range. On a tighter budget, the Jack Pyke Ashcombe uses a Nyco fabric bonded to a TPU membrane with a 5,000mm waterproof rating and a check lining.

Flat cap worn with Jack Pyke autumn and winter field clothing

For waxed cotton, the Jack Pyke Wax Flat Cap is made from 375gsm British Millerain waxed cotton with a cotton tartan lining and a popper on the peak. Treat it like a wax jacket: wipe off mud with cold water and re-wax when the finish looks dry. Our guide to re-waxing a Barbour jacket covers the method, and the same principles apply to a cap.

What is the best flat cap for shooting?

A shooting cap needs to stay put in the wind, keep rain off your glasses and sit comfortably with ear defenders. A shaped wool tweed cap with a water-repellent finish does all three.

Harkila Badanloch flat cap in Demitasse Brown British wool tweed

The Harkila Badanloch is made from 100% British wool tweed woven by Mallalieus of Delph, with a naturally water-repellent finish, a slightly padded satin lining and a shaped fit. Its rich tweed tones also blend into moorland surroundings. If you prefer the fuller eight-piece shape, the Harkila Benmore baker boy cap uses the same mill's wool tweed.

Some Guns prefer a peaked sports cap with ear defenders. The Barbour Wax Sports Cap has a rounded shape that Barbour designed to make wearing ear defenders more comfortable. You will find more options in our men's shooting hats and caps, and our guide to choosing a shooting jacket for pheasant season helps you match the rest of your kit.

Flat cap or baker boy cap?

A flat cap has a neat, low profile with the crown sewn close to the peak. A baker boy (also called a newsboy cap) is fuller, usually made from eight panels with a button on top, and sits more loosely on the head.

Flat caps suit a tidier, more traditional look and tend to stay on better in the wind. Baker boys are more relaxed and work well with casual country clothes. Both styles sell well with us: over the last three months, waxed and Harris Tweed baker boy caps have been among our best-selling caps, alongside the Stornoway flat caps.

How should a flat cap fit, and what size am I?

Flat cap paired with Jack Pyke country clothing on a cold day outdoors

A flat cap should sit firmly without leaving a red line on your forehead, with the peak just above your eyebrows. If it moves when you turn your head into the wind, it is too big.

To find your size, wrap a soft tape measure around your head about a finger's width above your ears and across the middle of your forehead. Many tweed caps, including Failsworth, are sized in centimetres, so you can match that number directly. Others use S to XL, as on the Barbour Barlow flat cap, a wool-blend cap with a fully lined crown and leather badge. If you fall between sizes, go up and let the sweatband do the work.

How do you clean and look after a tweed flat cap?

Most tweed flat caps should not go in the washing machine. Brush off dried mud with a soft clothes brush, spot clean marks with a little cold water, and let the cap dry naturally away from a radiator or fire, ideally over a rounded shape so it keeps its form.

Always check the care label first. For waterproof fabrics and membranes, a reproofer such as Grangers can help restore the water repellency once the surface stops beading. Waxed caps need re-waxing rather than reproofing.

Flat caps as a Christmas present

Flat cap worn with Jack Pyke countrywear in the field

A flat cap is one of the easiest country gifts to get right: it is practical, it lasts for years, and a centimetre-sized tweed cap is simple to choose if you can sneak a look at the size in an old one. If you are unsure, a cap sized S to XL is the safer bet. For more ideas, see our country Christmas gifts for winter clothing.

Frequently asked questions

How do you wear a flat cap?

Wear it level or tilted very slightly forward, with the peak just above your eyebrows. Pair tweed with wax jackets, quilted jackets and knitwear, and keep the colours in the same earthy family.

Can you put a flat cap in the washing machine?

Generally no. Wool tweed and waxed caps can shrink, lose their shape or lose their finish in a washing machine. Brush and spot clean instead, and always follow the care label.

Can you wear a flat cap in summer?

Yes, but a heavy winter tweed will feel warm. In summer, a lighter-weight cap or a cotton peaked cap is more comfortable.

Woman wearing a flat cap with an oversized striped shirt, polo knit and navy wellingtons

Can women wear flat caps?

Yes. Many flat caps are unisex in cut, and centimetre sizing makes it easy to find the right fit. Failsworth's tweed caps, for example, start at 55cm.

Are flat caps waterproof?

Not all of them. Traditional tweed is water-resistant rather than waterproof. Look for a waterproof tweed, a membrane cap or waxed cotton if you need protection from prolonged rain.

Find your flat cap

Browse our full range of caps and hats to compare tweeds, waxes and patterns. If you would like help with sizing or choosing between two caps, call the team on 01768 864211 or visit our shop, where you can try caps on in person. Dogs are welcome too.

Written by the John Norris of Penrith team. Published November 2026.


Share on


YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

  • Get the latest news and offers from John Norris of Penrith

    Sign Up To Our Newsletter To Receive A 10% Discount Code To Use On Your First Order.

    Offer excludes sales items, Fishpond, Lamson, Loon, McLean, Rio, Sage, Scientific Angler, Simms, Vision products and vouchers.